An employer runs a background check, sees a criminal record, and sends the candidate a rejection email that afternoon. The process felt clean. The record was real. The decision was defensible.

It was also very likely a violation of federal law, and the employer will not find out until a demand letter arrives.

Two Notices, Not One

The Fair Credit Reporting Act governs how an employer may act on a background report prepared by a third party. It does not prohibit rejecting someone over what the report says. It prohibits doing it in a single step.

The required sequence has three parts, and the middle one is the part employers skip.

Step one, the pre-adverse action notice. Before making the decision final, the employer gives the candidate a complete copy of the consumer report being relied on, along with the current written summary of rights under the Fair Credit Reporting Act published by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. The full report, not a summary the employer wrote, and not a description of what the report said.

Step two, the waiting period. The candidate needs time to review the report and dispute inaccuracies with the consumer reporting agency that produced it. The statute requires only that the copy of the report and the summary of rights come "before taking any adverse action" (15 U.S.C. 1681b(b)(3)(A)). It does not set a number of days, which is precisely why this step gets compressed. The Federal Trade Commission says the advance notice gives the person "the opportunity to review the report and tell you if it is correct." Many employers use five business days as a working practice, but that figure is a convention, not a legal rule.

Step three, the final adverse action notice. Only after the waiting period has elapsed. It tells the candidate the decision was made, identifies the consumer reporting agency, states that the agency did not make the decision and cannot explain it, and notifies the candidate of the right to a free copy of the report and the right to dispute its accuracy.

A risky shortcut is not skipping a notice. It is sending both notices within twenty four hours. A waiting period that does not allow time to obtain and review a report, contact the agency, and file a dispute is not a meaningful waiting period. Technically complete paperwork may not protect you if the candidate never had a real chance to respond.

State Law Is Tightening the Floor

Because the federal statute leaves the duration open, some states have begun setting their own. Under Washington's Fair Chance Act (RCW 49.94.010), an employer that intends to take adverse action based on an adult conviction record must notify the person, identify the record, and hold the position open for a minimum of two business days. The requirement applies to employers with 15 or more employees beginning July 1, 2026.

For a multi state employer this creates the familiar problem: the compliant process is the strictest one that applies to any candidate in the pipeline. Running a single national standard at five business days is simpler than tracking which candidate sits in which jurisdiction, and it would exceed Washington's two business day requirement.

What the Waiting Period Is For

The compliance framing makes this sound like a formality to document. It is not. Consumer reports can contain errors, and the candidate is often the person best positioned to identify them. The screening vendor cannot. The employer cannot. Only the person whose life the record describes knows whether it is accurate.

In our experience, three kinds of errors come up most often.

Identity collisions. A record belonging to a different person, matched on a common name and a partial date of birth. In our experience this is the most frequent error, and candidates with common surnames are more likely to be affected. A record attached to the wrong person reads exactly like a record attached to the right one.

Expunged and sealed records that still surface. A court ordered the record sealed, but the sealing did not propagate to every database the vendor pulls from. The candidate typically knows the disposition and can produce the order. Nobody else in the process can.

Date compression. A charge from eleven years ago can appear with a recent date, because the reported date is when the record was digitized rather than when the underlying event occurred. That distinction can decide whether an arrest or other non-conviction item is still reportable under the seven year rule in 15 U.S.C. 1681c, which does not apply to records of convictions, and whether the item is relevant to the role at all.

Each of these can be corrected, but not after a rejection email has already gone out.

What a Compliant Process Looks Like in Practice

Set a single waiting period and apply it to every candidate regardless of location. Five business days is a common working practice, not a statutory requirement, and applying it consistently helps show a fair process.

Send the complete report. Attaching the actual document is less work than summarizing it and it is what the statute requires.

Include the current summary of rights. It is revised periodically, and using a version from several years ago is an avoidable defect.

Give the candidate a name and a way to respond. A notice that arrives from a no reply address, with no path back to a human, is technically a notice and practically a dead end.

Document the dates. The date the pre-adverse notice was sent, the date the waiting period expired, and the date the final notice was sent. Three dates in a file are what demonstrates the process was followed, and reconstructing them later can be difficult.

Decide in advance what you do when a candidate disputes. Most employers have no answer, and the result is an application that sits untouched while the dispute resolves and the candidate takes another offer.

The Argument That Is Not About Compliance

Every part of this can be justified on legal exposure alone, and that argument is real. It is also the weaker one.

The stronger argument is that the waiting period is where you find out the record was not theirs. Employers who compress the process do not merely take on legal risk. They can quietly lose qualified candidates to somebody else's criminal history, and may never learn it happened, because the person they rejected had no way to tell them.

The candidate you were about to lose over a name collision is still available on day five.

How TrueScan HR Helps

TrueScan HR does not run background checks. It scores the resume against the job before any background check is ordered, and it shows the matched and missing skills behind the score, so the qualification decision is documented on its own and does not get mixed into the adverse action process. Run a free scan to see it on one of your own openings.

Related guide: For California candidate data requests, see How to Answer a Candidate Data Request in California.

Sources:

This post is general information, not legal advice. TrueScan HR is not a law firm. Confirm how these rules apply to your organization with employment counsel.