Most coverage of artificial intelligence and hiring law asks what an employer must do. One federal case in California asks a different question: can the company that sells the screening software be held responsible, even though it did not hire anyone? That case is Mobley v. Workday, and it is back in the news this month because Workday has asked the judge to break it apart.
This post explains what the case is, what the court has and has not decided, what Workday filed on November 10, 2026, and what it means whether you are applying for jobs or buying hiring software. It is general information, not legal advice.
What the Case Is About
Derek Mobley, a man over 40, sued Workday in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. He alleges that Workday's artificial intelligence applicant recommendation system discriminated against older applicants. According to HR Dive's May 19, 2025 report, Mobley and four other plaintiffs said they received hundreds of quick rejections without interviews. The claim is brought under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), and it is a disparate impact theory. That means the plaintiffs do not have to prove anyone intended to discriminate. They argue that a neutral-looking practice falls harder on a protected group.
Workday says the case lacks merit. Its position, as HR Dive reports, is that the claims should be dismissed once the facts are presented. Nothing in the record described below is a finding that Workday's software discriminated against anyone.
What the Court Decided in 2025
On May 16, 2025, Judge Rita Lin allowed the age claim to proceed as a collective action. Holland & Knight describes the ruling as a nationwide collective of applicants aged 40 and older who were denied employment recommendations through Workday's platform since September 24, 2020. People in that group must opt in to join. The same firm notes that the court "recognized Mobley's claim as plausible under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act" and cautions that "the court's decision is only preliminary."
Two details from that ruling matter for anyone watching the case. First, Judge Lin rejected Workday's proposed sliding-scale standard for deciding whether applicants are similarly situated. Second, she addressed the practical objection that the group could be enormous. HR Dive quotes her: "Allegedly widespread discrimination is not a basis for denying notice." The scale is not small. Husch Blackwell reports that Workday itself said about 1.1 billion applications were rejected during the relevant period.
Why "Preliminary" Is the Important Word
Husch Blackwell explains that collective certification in the Ninth Circuit happens in two steps. At the first step, the plaintiffs only need to plausibly show that the group members are similarly situated, which is a relatively low bar. If the court agrees, notice goes out and people can opt in. After discovery, the defendant can ask the court to decertify, and the court then takes what the firm calls "a more exacting look" at the record.
That second step is where the case is now. Workday has not lost on the merits, and the plaintiffs have not won on the merits. The court has said only that the question is worth answering with the evidence in hand.
What Workday Filed on November 10, 2026
According to Startup Fortune's November 12, 2026 report, Workday filed two requests in San Francisco federal court. The first asks Judge Lin to decertify the age discrimination collective, which the report says covers more than 15,000 applicants who opted in, and to dismiss their claims without prejudice so they could file individual cases. The second, in a separate filing, asks the court to block a wider group of applicants from pursuing race, sex, age, and disability claims together.
The same report says these are motions, not rulings, that Judge Lin has not decided them, and that a class certification hearing is set for March 2027. This post relies on press reporting and not on the filings themselves, so check the court docket (case number 3:23-cv-00770 in the Northern District of California) for the current status.
The Question Underneath: Who Is Responsible for a Screening Tool?
Workday's central argument, as the coverage describes it, is that its customers make the hiring decisions and that customer settings differ from one employer to the next. The plaintiffs argue that a vendor whose software ranks and rejects applicants takes part in the decision. Courts have not finished sorting out that question, and it would be a mistake to assume either side has the answer.
What the case does show is that "the vendor did it" and "the employer did it" are not the only two possibilities. A tool, its configuration, and the people who turn the dials can all become part of the story. That connects directly to the two dismissals we covered earlier this month. In our post on two courts that dismissed screening bias claims, the applicants lost at the pleading stage because they could not point to a specific practice or to group-level facts. The Workday plaintiffs got further, in part because they are challenging one named vendor system applied across many employers, and because the court was willing to let a group-wide question be tested with evidence.
For Job Seekers: What Is Practical Right Now
- Keep a record of every application. Date, job title, posting link, and outcome. Save a copy of the posting, since postings are often removed.
- Watch for the notice process in any case you may be eligible for. Collective actions like this one rely on people opting in, and the opt-in rules and deadlines are set by the court. If you believe you may be covered by a case, an employment attorney can tell you what applies to you.
- Write your resume so a filter can read it. Quick rejections often come from simple matching. Our post on why keyword matching is not hiring intelligence explains how the same skill described in different words can be missed.
- Keep expectations realistic. A lawsuit moving forward is not proof of wrongdoing, and nothing here promises a particular outcome for any applicant.
For Employers: Buying a Tool Does Not Hand Off the Responsibility
Whatever Judge Lin decides, the practical lesson for an employer is the same. A vendor contract does not remove your need to understand what your own hiring process does. Consider these steps.
- List every automated step. Include recommendations, scores, auto-reject rules, and knockout questions, and note which were switched on by default. Our ATS filter audit checklist shows how to build that list.
- Ask your vendor direct questions. What inputs does the system use, has it been tested for differences in outcomes by age and other protected traits, and what documentation can the vendor share?
- Review your own outcomes by group. Selection rates are your data, not the vendor's. Our post on what an AI hiring bias audit should contain describes a useful review.
- Keep screening records. If something is challenged later, being able to show how each candidate was handled is a strong starting point, though no record can promise a result.
Where TrueScan HR Fits
TrueScan HR scores a resume against the job description and shows the matched and missing skills behind every score. The goal is a result that a recruiter can read and question, and a job seeker can learn from, instead of an unexplained rejection. Visibility into why a candidate scored the way they did is also what makes the audit steps above possible. TrueScan HR does not decide who gets hired, and it is not a substitute for legal advice or for a review of your own process.
The Bottom Line
Mobley v. Workday is unresolved. The age collective was allowed to proceed in 2025, Workday has now asked the court to undo it, and a hearing on the wider class is set for March 2027. Applicants and employers should not treat the case as a verdict against screening software, and should not treat it as a distant story about someone else. It is a live test of who answers for an automated screen, and the sensible response on either side of the table is to understand the tools in use, keep good records, and watch the docket.
Sources:
- Federal Court Allows Collective Action Lawsuit Over Alleged AI Hiring Bias, Holland & Knight, May 27, 2025
- Judge allows Workday AI bias lawsuit to proceed as collective action, HR Dive, May 19, 2025
- California Court Grants Preliminary Collective Certification to Job Applicants Claiming Age Discrimination by Artificial Intelligence, Husch Blackwell, July 29, 2025
- Workday asks a federal judge to break up the AI hiring bias case against it, Startup Fortune, November 12, 2026